It is pretty surprising that despite having undergone several sexual harassment/ molestation incidents throughout my childhood and young adulthood I have ended up being fairly scar-free of those emotional traumas. I don't know how or why. I definitely had my parents’ unspoken support and that gave me strength. And I read books and articles on the matter like crazy – they made me realize that it was not my fault. But it was brutal going through all that starting from a very young age of (perhaps) 3 and a half or four years. My first memory of such an incident is not visual. It is more related to sounds and touches. The molester was a teenage girl (or probably in her early 20s).
From then on, I was fair game like every other girl in India is, to these beasts. I have lost count of the number of times I was harassed on the streets, molested by people I (or my parents) trusted AND the number of years I believed that all this happened to me because I was promiscuous. I do, still, remember the shame I felt, the fear and the frustration that gripped me and the rage that shook me every time something like this happened. What’s worse was that I had NO ONE to talk to, about all this. The few times I did have to ask for other people's help, I was chastised for having brought it upon myself (never by my parents though).
One incident that stands out in my mind is from when I was 9 or 10, in 5th grade. A family friend's son had moved in with us because his family had to move to some other town and he was waiting for a room to become available in his college's hostel. One day he called me to his room to show me something. I don't remember what it was but while I was looking at it, he placed me in his lap and started grinding himself into me. I ran away from there at the first opportunity I could find. All this happened while my mom was in the next room. I told her what happened and within a few days he was gone. This unspoken support gave me strength but I feel it would have helped me greatly if my mom had talked to me about it, explained how it was not my fault. So, even though my parents showed their support for me by their actions, I grew up believing that every such thing that happened to me happened only because I somehow brought it on myself.
These molesters can be anywhere. I remember how a close friend of my dad, would squeeze my breasts every time he came over (which was often). I was probably 9 at that time. He was bold enough to do it unobtrusively, right in the presence of my parents! I am sure he got that confidence from the fact that the Indian society does not believe in talking about these things openly. So he was confident that the shame and guilt will keep me quiet. It did. I was fortunate that this, and almost all other incidents, didn’t escalate into more serious sexual abuse. Maybe my parents noticed it and avoided situations that could result in a terrible situation but it would definitely have helped if they had also talked to me about it - would have saved me from years of angst and guilt.
These experiences taught me never to trust anyone and never to ask for help. To this day, even though I have overcome the shame, the fear and the frustration, I still cannot bring myself to trust anyone fully. And it still isn't easy for me to ask for help. Small price to pay for being scar-free, I think.
Thankfully, it hasn't made me a paranoid parent. Yes, I worry about my girls' safety, and I am not naive about the dangers lurking out there. But I refuse to let that fear make me restrict them to the point of suffocation. S goes on sleepovers and stays overnight at our friends' places. I am slowly encouraging her to step out on her own and find her footing. I'll be there if she needs help but I will NOT lead the way. I believe she will gain tremendous confidence from finding her own way with me and J by her side, like I did with my parents' help.
These experiences have taught me the importance of keeping an open communication channel with my daughters. I keep the conversation going about how to recognize the signs of sexual harassment, how one should trust their gut instinct in such matters and how it is NOT THE VICTIM'S FAULT. Not even if the victim were dressed in inappropriate clothing.
This last one originated from a comment my older daughter, S, made when I broached this subject right before she left for an overnight field trip. As I explained to her how she should trust her gut instincts and tackle such situations, and how it is NEVER the girl's fault if she is harassed or molested, she turned to me and said "unless she is wearing really inappropriate clothing, right?" I was gobsmacked!! I have NEVER expressed this opinion. I don't subscribe to it. I don't know where or whom she picked it from. But I am glad she mentioned it because then I got a chance to correct her.
I explained to her that even if a girl is dressed highly inappropriately, even if she is running around naked, it is NOT right for anyone to molest her. It would be just like taking, say, a purse from Macy's display just because no one is looking and the purse is very pretty and within easy reach. The law won't excuse you for that. Similarly how can it be okay for someone to harass a woman just because she is within easy reach or an easy target? That is the problem with this entire situation - we (as a society) tend to blame the woman for "inviting it upon herself" instead of blaming the man for not being able to control his animal urges. Isn't that what being an adult (and a civilized being) all about? Controlling urges that could harm others? Why not expect the men to control themselves? Why do we let men off so easily?
I hope S understood what I was trying to say. I hope these conversations help her in some way because I can only imagine how they could have helped me get over the guilt I felt almost my entire childhood. And I hope I can keep these communication channels open to help make my daughters strong enough to deal with such situations.
I know I cannot protect my daughters forever. But I can empower them to handle all kinds of situations. I can remind them, again and again, that they can come to me and their dad if they need help or support. And I will educate them on the matter so they go out in the big, bad world with their eyes and ears open.
We all need to talk about CSA more. Not talking about it openly sends a message to our kids that it is something shameful if you are a victim of it. We need to place the shame where it belongs – on the abuser. We need to create an environment in our homes that will encourage our kids to come talk to us instead of wallowing in shame or hurt. Almost always, abusers get away with their deeds just because the victims stay quiet out of shame or confusion. If we remove the barrier to the victims’ free speech, it will take away the cloak of security from the abuser. THAT is what will empower the children.
Great post, Cee. Totally agree. Empowering kids beats suffocating them any day
ReplyDeleteGreat post.One question. How old is your daughter when you brought up the subject? I have a toddler and wondering when I should start talking to her about this.
ReplyDeleteLike Rohini said, it is all in empowering them. Hugs CK and I think despite all the shitty experiences, you are a very strong woman and for that, I will always look up to you as a role model.
ReplyDeleteHugs. This is such a balanced post. Yes, you suffered it, but at least could approach your parents, and you learned what they could've done better, and are doing it for your daughters.
ReplyDeleteI too believe that overprotecting just is not okay, it's like letting the b^#%$@ds win, so that we women and children cower with fear. NO WAY. We have to find our voices and go out there to claim what is rightfully ours, freedom, equality and respect from others and ourselves.
Ro: Thanks. Empowering instead of suffocating, listening, paying attention... These things are so obvious! It makes me mad that the generation before us couldn't figure this out.
ReplyDeleteWhatsup: Thanks for dropping by. My older daughter, S, is 12. Younger one, M, is 3. With S I have conversations like the one I wrote about in this post. With M, I have started talking about good touch-bad touch in the most basic terms. Like telling her that any part of her body that is covered by her undergarments is off limits to anyone except when mommy, daddy or did are helping her shower or get dressed. There are a few other things I do - maybe I should write a post on it. It will get too long for a comment.
ReplyDeleteHow old is your daughter? Start by showing her that if she says "no" (like when she is being tickled), she will be heard. It is a fine line because you don't want to honor a "no" when it is said in reply to "finish your vegetables" :)
Shobana: Thanks, you are being too kind. Hugs back.
ReplyDeleteStarry: You are so right!! It always burned me that it was me, THE VICTIM, who had to carry the shame and hide while the abusers roamed freely.
ReplyDeleteMy daughter is 20 Months old. Having gone through similar things, I worry a lot about CSA to the extent that I dont want her to go to India and am very uncomfortable when we are around lot of Indian men.
ReplyDeleteWhatsup: I agree with you totally! I didn't get comfortable letting S go anywhere unsupervised until she was old enough to speak up if something bothered her. M doesn't get to go unsupervised anywhere yet either. And I am teaching her to be vocal about whatever displeases her. I'll wait to let her go on sleepovers (just like I did with S) until she is at least 7 or 8, maybe older, depending on her maturity level.
ReplyDeleteGreat post, great topic. Ceekay, hats off to you for bringing this up. I honestly think that no girl grows up without having to go through atleast a few such traumatic experiences. A touch here, lewd comment there can fill the mind with angst and guilt.I have two daughters- 4 and 1 and i've already started telling the elder one about good touch,bad touch etc.
ReplyDelete